• Welcome to TalkWeather!
    We see you lurking around TalkWeather! Take the extra step and join us today to view attachments, see less ads and maybe even join the discussion.
    CLICK TO JOIN TALKWEATHER
Logo 468x120

Marshal79344

Member
Messages
361
Reaction score
1,066
Location
Chicago, IL
The more that I dive into the Cookeville, Tennessee EF4 Tornado of March 3rd, 2020, the more I'm astonished by its nature. In particular, the meteorology behind the Cookeville tornado is more interesting to me the more that I think about it. First of all, when the supercell produced the Nashville Tornado, it was in an environment with slightly more instability and slightly less lower-level shear and streamwise vorticity compared to when it produced the Cookeville tornado. In addition, the supercell had a clear inflow notch to the south with no form of obstruction when it produced the Nashville Tornado, compared to when it produced the Cookeville Tornado. Either, I would think that this means that the increase in shear either over-compensated for the decrease in instability, or that put both tornadoes on a level playing field, but the Cookeville tornado's narrow high-end damage swath and the law of the conservation of angular momentum explain its significantly higher intensity compared to the Nashville tornado's broader intense damage swath.

In addition, the tornado's sudden intensification is quite interesting. The tornado remained a relatively large but weak tornado for the first two miles before suddenly, as it entered the western part of the Echo Hills subdivision, a strong subvortex descended from the ground. It was only a block wide and gradually intensified until the instant the tornado reached Hensley Drive. When the tornado devastated the southern side of the homes along Hensley Drive at, in my opinion, mid-rage EF4 intensity, the wind field became much more complex and suddenly seemed to "thrash out" at points. This is illustrated below as the storm approached McBroom Chapel Road.

1665490065003.png



The grove of trees located behind the homes on the southern side of Hensley Drive also showed signs of violent tornado wind impact. They were completely denuded and partially debarked, as shown below. The wind field then seemed to shrink to a width of no more than three homes in a tightly packed subdivision for the rest of its life and weakened normally. The damage also seemed to peak in intensity at Hensley Drive, when the EF3+ wind field was at its most inconsistent and complex, which I think is interesting to note.

The grove of trees that was entirely denuded and partially debarked:

20200303COOKEVILLE13.jpg
20200303COOKEVILLE15.jpg
 
Messages
22
Reaction score
49
Location
Hume, Virginia
Doing a bit on research on a local VA Sigtor. The Rocky Mount EF3 came back up. I remember talking to a local Met about how extreme the damage cutoff was in the woods, just recently found examples of it while searching for an F2 from 9/17/04. Kinda impressed with the tree damage this caused. Photos sourced from: shttps://www.facebook.com/MeteorologistJamieArnold/posts/pfbid0mB6n3UWeAgxgUhKjVjrNyxL94iFNcEXKscNnJajwJiJjn4UtXhujXGzbVxyUG266l 1665712599455.png1665712579831.png
 

CalebRoutt

Member
Messages
75
Reaction score
97
Location
Kentucky
I would list Holly Springs 12/23/2015 (however poorly documented it was by the survey teams) and the 6/28/2018 Camp Crook "EF3" as definite EF5's and all of the Pilger family tornadoes except Wakefield are good EF5 contenders as well (if you had to hold me at one though, Stanton would be my pick).

Might as well also add that I will say it's POSSIBLE Doran MN 6/17/2010 and Henryville 3/2/2012 were EF5s, I feel they definitely were capable of causing damage within the EF5 threshold but I'm a bit on the fence about them overall.
Henryville didn’t have the construction quality for an EF5 rating, but the asphalt ripped, debris granulation in New Pekin, downtown Henryville, and Marysville could arguably suggest higher-end EF4+.
 

Attachments

  • E2663F2B-744F-4E50-B08C-0867323BEC48.png
    E2663F2B-744F-4E50-B08C-0867323BEC48.png
    8.8 MB · Views: 0
  • 7305DF9C-F0CA-4BE9-8AD5-FABF085C6BFE.jpeg
    7305DF9C-F0CA-4BE9-8AD5-FABF085C6BFE.jpeg
    1.6 MB · Views: 0
  • EC3B4A33-2872-407A-AB10-356718E8EB08.jpeg
    EC3B4A33-2872-407A-AB10-356718E8EB08.jpeg
    127.8 KB · Views: 0
  • D6105C4D-3836-4772-9257-4A0508A8F972.jpeg
    D6105C4D-3836-4772-9257-4A0508A8F972.jpeg
    225.4 KB · Views: 0
Messages
22
Reaction score
49
Location
Hume, Virginia
Been researching the New Years Outbreak of 2010-2011, and I recently found out that facebook has a gold mine of photos from the Sunset Hills, MO EF3. Personally I believe had the EF4 not occurred a few months later in the interior suburbs, this tornado would be talked about far more. Find this day really interesting, mainly because timing and the amount of intense tornadoes that occurred on this day.




1665882841730.png
 

szh1996

Member
Messages
4
Reaction score
4
Location
Seattle

szh1996

Member
Messages
4
Reaction score
4
Location
Seattle
One thing that may worth mentioned here was I think the oil rig was very likely not a direct hit by El Reno tornado. The centerline determination was mostly from all ground scouring pictures what I can collect.
View attachment 11844
Two pictures West of N courtney Road help me to determine the centerline
View attachment 11845View attachment 11846
The center of the tornado seems already acrossed Us.66 in industry area. Tornado was also shrinking its size and later weakened before reintensified after 21:18 based on RaxPol and damage.
Wow, its core didn’t hit the oil rig and it still lifted and tossed the huge thing over some distance. Should be the strongest example of lifting heavy objects. Maybe only 1990 Bakersfield Valley tornado could rival (Carried three 80-tonne oil tanks about 5 km)
 

CalebRoutt

Member
Messages
75
Reaction score
97
Location
Kentucky
Wow, its core didn’t hit the oil rig and it still lifted and tossed the huge thing over some distance. Should be the strongest example of lifting heavy objects. Maybe only 1990 Bakersfield Valley tornado could rival (Carried three 80-tonne oil tanks about 5 km)
it was hit by the tornado’s strong side so it’s likely that the peak winds were there and not necessarily at the core
 

CalebRoutt

Member
Messages
75
Reaction score
97
Location
Kentucky
I’ve always thought the 2011 Springfield EF3 was likely EF4 in areas such as Brimfield and Monson. The tree damage was absolutely incredible, and at least 2 anchor bolted homes were totally leveled. A large vehicle repair shop was also destroyed with the exception of a few walls and was within an area of debarked/denuded trees.
 

Attachments

  • CC78D40F-DAF2-47D6-94F0-2770D5684EA0.jpeg
    CC78D40F-DAF2-47D6-94F0-2770D5684EA0.jpeg
    212.4 KB · Views: 0
  • 0BC33C6C-4B45-46DC-89DB-C3B8EC44E8AE.jpeg
    0BC33C6C-4B45-46DC-89DB-C3B8EC44E8AE.jpeg
    402.2 KB · Views: 0
  • 98182529-FB08-4803-809C-1816D23DFC49.jpeg
    98182529-FB08-4803-809C-1816D23DFC49.jpeg
    237.1 KB · Views: 0
  • 9AD516E9-DFC9-4AA8-B38E-DE2E8D9076B8.jpeg
    9AD516E9-DFC9-4AA8-B38E-DE2E8D9076B8.jpeg
    184.9 KB · Views: 0
  • 1FE1E736-BF1C-4C7B-B24E-1F7614604786.jpeg
    1FE1E736-BF1C-4C7B-B24E-1F7614604786.jpeg
    174.8 KB · Views: 0
  • 43D42986-87B2-48ED-ABDE-64386D9AC44C.jpeg
    43D42986-87B2-48ED-ABDE-64386D9AC44C.jpeg
    1.1 MB · Views: 0
  • 2114947E-F892-4505-A2C4-39FBA879FC5C.jpeg
    2114947E-F892-4505-A2C4-39FBA879FC5C.jpeg
    1.3 MB · Views: 0
  • 900948C8-AEE2-4A9E-8D9F-4DAF43FEEBFF.jpeg
    900948C8-AEE2-4A9E-8D9F-4DAF43FEEBFF.jpeg
    1.3 MB · Views: 0
  • 2FCD5FC3-BB4E-426B-94B9-B275A58A0266.jpeg
    2FCD5FC3-BB4E-426B-94B9-B275A58A0266.jpeg
    1.4 MB · Views: 0
  • 2CD94D4D-DC1F-4CFA-8FA2-541FF342D163.jpeg
    2CD94D4D-DC1F-4CFA-8FA2-541FF342D163.jpeg
    1.1 MB · Views: 0

Western_KS_Wx

Member
Messages
210
Reaction score
592
Location
Garden City KS
I’ve always thought the 2011 Springfield EF3 was likely EF4 in areas such as Brimfield and Monson. The tree damage was absolutely incredible, and at least 2 anchor bolted homes were totally leveled. A large vehicle repair shop was also destroyed with the exception of a few walls and was within an area of debarked/denuded trees.
That tornado was incredible and exceptionally anomalous for that region, pretty much a violent, long-lived dixie alley tornado but dropped in Massachusetts. The tornadoes appearance was also monstrous. Like you said, damage in and around Brimfield was very likely indicative of EF4 intensity.
56E529D4-E215-4951-B208-508A3B1C8C1A.jpeg
8D0D05A0-A76B-43F5-B5C0-AB77617C140E.png
0B7E0ECA-7632-458C-9AA2-C6A20617C89B.jpeg
451E9357-F640-46A1-944E-A0A6FCA88A0F.jpeg
D370086D-AA7A-406D-ADA6-58C520D4E143.jpeg
F1E3415C-C6F8-4A03-AB3E-DCF6A36B445D.jpeg
3A7F82DE-2A66-41A2-9383-B3B53F9F0316.jpeg
 

Tanner

Member
Messages
260
Reaction score
454
Location
Granville, MA
That tornado was incredible and exceptionally anomalous for that region, pretty much a violent, long-lived dixie alley tornado but dropped in Massachusetts. The tornadoes appearance was also monstrous. Like you said, damage in and around Brimfield was very likely indicative of EF4 intensity.
View attachment 15241
View attachment 15242
View attachment 15243
View attachment 15244
View attachment 15245
View attachment 15246
View attachment 15247

I wish I had the ability to add more in terms of information and photos, but living in Western Mass and seeing the damage first-hand, I always felt as if the tornado reached violent status.

Highly overshadowed by the previous weeks and months, but the effect that the tornado had on Springfield and the smaller communities was massive. Like you said, basically a dixie-like tornado but further north. We have similarities in our terrain as well.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

CalebRoutt

Member
Messages
75
Reaction score
97
Location
Kentucky
That tornado was incredible and exceptionally anomalous for that region, pretty much a violent, long-lived dixie alley tornado but dropped in Massachusetts. The tornadoes appearance was also monstrous. Like you said, damage in and around Brimfield was very likely indicative of EF4 intensity.
View attachment 15241
View attachment 15242
View attachment 15243
View attachment 15244
View attachment 15245
View attachment 15246
View attachment 15247
The setup was more akin to the 5/27 2019 Dayton Ohio setup. While that tornado was moving somewhat quickly, it wasn’t moving at the same speed as other violent tornadoes that year (Tuscaloosa, Hackleburg, Cordova etc). Terrain was absolutely a huge factor in that tornado. Im almost certain if you took the Vrot + the volume extent of the tree damage you could easily get an EF4 rating. In fact IMO it was.
 

CalebRoutt

Member
Messages
75
Reaction score
97
Location
Kentucky
Not to mention this thing had a well-defined TBSS caused by debris lofted to around 24,000 ft ARL and a Vrot of 75.3 kts. 4 out of the top 5 analogs using the same TDS/Vrot in the Dual Pol era has the max winds at 170-180 mph where the Vrot and TDS were at it's highest over Brimfield. The video of the tornado in that area was absolutely incredible, and the near total debarking of trees screams violent tornado. I do think most of the homes it hit were poorly constructed though.
 

Attachments

  • 6042dsss121dkbox_20110601_2104_BR_0.5.png
    6042dsss121dkbox_20110601_2104_BR_0.5.png
    419.2 KB · Views: 0
  • 09BCA9BE-89B3-4646-A3F0-C2B8894D6A74.jpeg
    09BCA9BE-89B3-4646-A3F0-C2B8894D6A74.jpeg
    490.7 KB · Views: 0
  • Capture.PNG
    Capture.PNG
    188.1 KB · Views: 0
  • Capture2.PNG
    Capture2.PNG
    138 KB · Views: 0

TH2002

Member
Sustaining Member
Messages
3,168
Reaction score
4,808
Location
California, United States
Special Affiliations
  1. SKYWARN® Volunteer
During the latter part of the original F-scale's run in the United States (particularly from 2004-2006), many tornadoes were underrated and in my opinion the 2006 Gallatin tornado is one of them. This tornado was actually rated F4 initially but downgraded to F3 in subsequent surveys revealing poor construction in the Woodhaven subdivision of Gallatin, although the downgrade didn't seem to take into account more well-built homes such as these:
sumner048.JPG

sumner029.JPG


Many vehicles were also mangled in a fashion not inconsistent with a more violent tornado.
sumner041.JPG

sumner089.JPG

sumner116.JPG

sumner111.JPG


Some possible light ground scouring here? Note the mud splattering on this vehicle:
sumner110.JPG
 
Back
Top