• Welcome to TalkWeather!
    We see you lurking around TalkWeather! Take the extra step and join us today to view attachments, see less ads and maybe even join the discussion.
    CLICK TO JOIN TALKWEATHER

Significant Tornado Events

Strongest tornadoes by month, at least since 1950:
January: Allendale, IL - 1/7/1989 - probable F5
February: Delhi, LA - 2/21/1971 - rated F5 or Clinton, AR - 2/5/2008 - probable F5
March: Hesston, KS - 3/13/1990 - rated F5
An embarrasment of riches for the months April - June; I won't try to pick one for each, but, from what I've read, the strongest contenders for each include several from SO 1974 and SO 2011 for April, almost too many to count for May, and Flint-Beecher (6/8/1953) and Bakersfield Valley (6/1/1990) for June
July: Oakfield, WI - 7/18/1996 - rated F5
August: Plainfield, IL - 8/18/1990 - rated F5, and appears to be the strongest August twister, but the F5 rating is often reasonably disputed
September: Cobb Town, WI - 9/26/1951 - probable F5
October: Belmond, IA - 10/14/1966 - probable F4 but was rated, most likely incorrectly, as F5; I don't see any other F5 contenders from October
November: Washington, IL - 11/17/2013 - borderline F5, probably was one
December: Holly Springs, MS - 12/23/2015 - almost certainly an F5; may well have been stronger than Mayfield-Bremen
January: I think the F4 rating for Allendale is fine, since the homes it destroyed were poorly anchored to cinder block foundations (hell, it would probably get an EF3 rating the way damage surveys are these days). Not aware of any true (E)F5 contenders for the month of January but I think the 1988 Liberty Chapel, MS tornado and 1997 Barfield, TN tornado are contenders for the strongest.

March: for post-1950 I would agree with Hesston, but for the month in general it's Tri-State hands down.

September: will bring up Crosstown 2006 as another contender for the strongest September tornado, as at least one of the homes it slabbed was reportedly well anchored. Don't think it's a solid F5 candidate though as it didn't really produce any extremely impressive contextual damage.

October: the only October tornado I think is a genuine F5 contender is (ironically) the 1979 Windsor Locks, Connecticut tornado. Produced what is likely the most violent damage documented in New England. Numerous homes swept away, trees and low-lying shrubbery shredded and debarked, grass scoured to bare soil, and a 60-ton airplane carried 50 meters and snapped into three pieces.
 
So what are some EF4s or even below that have produced contextual damage of near or at EF5 intensity or have an argument for EF5? Besides the well known ones like Chickasha, Goldsby, Vilonia, Mayfield, Chapman etc. Always wondered.
 
So what are some EF4s or even below that have produced contextual damage of near or at EF5 intensity or have an argument for EF5? Besides the well known ones like Chickasha, Goldsby, Vilonia, Mayfield, Chapman etc. Always wondered.
Many have been discussed in this thread over the years (I've read through all of it as time permits). Besides the ones you mentioned, many major tornadoes have been mentioned as having F5 potential

Some of the most notable contenders are
Worcester 53
Cygnet OH 53
Silverton TX 57
About 5-7 tornadoes from Palm Sunday 65
Wolbach, Nebraska 65
Cary-Tillatoba MS 71
Union City OK 73
Windsor Locks CT 79
Barrie, Ontario 85
Bakersfield Valley TX 90
Stratton NE 90
Winfield KS and Red Rock OK 91
Pampa, Allison, and Kellerville tx 95
Loyal Valley TX 99
Van Wert OH 02
Girard KS 03
Harper KS 04
Noot Farm ND 04
Westminster TX 06
Clinton AR 08
Picher OK - Neosho MO 08
New Wren MS 11
Berlin ND 11
Washington IL 13
All of Stanton, Pilger, Coleridge, and Alpena SD were f5 contenders
Louisville MS 14
Rochelle-Fairdale IL 15
Holly Springs MS 15
Matador TX 23

I won't attempt to comment on which deserve a higher rating

I will say New Wren is probably the worst IMO. It was rated F3. Look up the Tornado Talk summary. That was an absolutely vicious storm.
 
One of the most forgotten major tornadoes of the 1950s is the 5/15/1957 Silverton TX F4 tornado. This deadly night-time tornado tore a 250-yard wide path through the town of Silverton, killing 20-21 people and injuring 80. Numerous homes (many of which were newly constructed) were completely swept away or leveled. One of these homes reportedly had its brick foundation destroyed. Large tanker trucks were thrown 75 yards, a 2.5-ton gasoline tank was reportedly carried 1.5 miles, cars were thrown up to or over 200 yards, and some vehicles were mangled beyond recognition. A cotton gin was reportedly ripped out of the ground and destroyed and "portions of farm fields look like they were plowed with a big plow."
s-l400.jpg

1957-Tornado-Damaged-Lumsden-Perkins-Cotton-Gin-Lubbock.jpg

92818310_10221041733540673_4952936640566788096_n.jpg

10155271_1467118593522450_3249285756200875441_n.jpg

img

unknown.png

unknown.png
Is it just me or the rest of the photos won't load?
 
Wouldn't be surprised if this has been covered here before,
January: I think the F4 rating for Allendale is fine, since the homes it destroyed were poorly anchored to cinder block foundations (hell, it would probably get an EF3 rating the way damage surveys are these days). Not aware of any true (E)F5 contenders for the month of January but I think the 1988 Liberty Chapel, MS tornado and 1997 Barfield, TN tornado are contenders for the strongest.

March: for post-1950 I would agree with Hesston, but for the month in general it's Tri-State hands down.

September: will bring up Crosstown 2006 as another contender for the strongest September tornado, as at least one of the homes it slabbed was reportedly well anchored. Don't think it's a solid F5 candidate though as it didn't really produce any extremely impressive contextual damage.

October: the only October tornado I think is a genuine F5 contender is (ironically) the 1979 Windsor Locks, Connecticut tornado. Produced what is likely the most violent damage documented in New England. Numerous homes swept away, trees and low-lying shrubbery shredded and debarked, grass scoured to bare soil, and a 60-ton airplane carried 50 meters and snapped into three pieces.
Do you have sources or pics for the debarking and scouring with Windsor Locks?
 
Some more damage shots from Windsor Locks. A few of the homes that were swept away appear to have been anchor bolted to their foundations. While high end F4 is fine for this tornado, I'd probably side with a low-end F5 rating tbh. As far as intensity goes it was basically a mini-Worcester, briefly attaining its peak intensity over Poquonock Avenue, Settler Circle and the eastern side of Bradley International Airport.
aerial-Settler-Circle-Poquonock-Ave-after-some-tornado-cleanup-10t-6-1979-2019.12.1.jpg

screenshot-2023-03-28-at-01-19-26-windsor-1-jpg-webp-image-770-%C3%97-1024-pixels-%E2%80%94-scaled-65-png.19274

screenshot-2023-03-28-at-01-19-33-windsor-2-jpg-jpeg-image-612-%C3%97-322-pixels-png.19275

6864712_600x.jpg

1979TORNADO30-vi.jpg

Windsorlocks1.png
1979TORNADOJOURNALINQUIRER12-vi.jpg

the-windsor-locks-ct-f4-10-3-1979-v0-n0h41vu4s3qb1.jpg

the-windsor-locks-ct-f4-10-3-1979-v0-33jnunk5s3qb1.jpg


1979TORNADOADAYAFTER38-vi.jpg
 
Some more damage shots from Windsor Locks. A few of the homes that were swept away appear to have been anchor bolted to their foundations. While high end F4 is fine for this tornado, I'd probably side with a low-end F5 rating tbh. As far as intensity goes it was basically a mini-Worcester, briefly attaining its peak intensity over Poquonock Avenue, Settler Circle and the eastern side of Bradley International Airport.
aerial-Settler-Circle-Poquonock-Ave-after-some-tornado-cleanup-10t-6-1979-2019.12.1.jpg

screenshot-2023-03-28-at-01-19-26-windsor-1-jpg-webp-image-770-%C3%97-1024-pixels-%E2%80%94-scaled-65-png.19274

screenshot-2023-03-28-at-01-19-33-windsor-2-jpg-jpeg-image-612-%C3%97-322-pixels-png.19275

6864712_600x.jpg

1979TORNADO30-vi.jpg

View attachment 29080
1979TORNADOJOURNALINQUIRER12-vi.jpg

the-windsor-locks-ct-f4-10-3-1979-v0-n0h41vu4s3qb1.jpg

the-windsor-locks-ct-f4-10-3-1979-v0-33jnunk5s3qb1.jpg


1979TORNADOADAYAFTER38-vi.jpg
Wow…i have to check these locations out. Too close to home.
 
Strongest tornadoes by month, at least since 1950:
January: Allendale, IL - 1/7/1989 - probable F5
February: Delhi, LA - 2/21/1971 - rated F5 or Clinton, AR - 2/5/2008 - probable F5
March: Hesston, KS - 3/13/1990 - rated F5
An embarrasment of riches for the months April - June; I won't try to pick one for each, but, from what I've read, the strongest contenders for each include several from SO 1974 and SO 2011 for April, almost too many to count for May, and Flint-Beecher (6/8/1953) and Bakersfield Valley (6/1/1990) for June
July: Oakfield, WI - 7/18/1996 - rated F5
August: Plainfield, IL - 8/18/1990 - rated F5, and appears to be the strongest August twister, but the F5 rating is often reasonably disputed
September: Cobb Town, WI - 9/26/1951 - probable F5
October: Belmond, IA - 10/14/1966 - probable F4 but was rated, most likely incorrectly, as F5; I don't see any other F5 contenders from October
November: Washington, IL - 11/17/2013 - borderline F5, probably was one
December: Holly Springs, MS - 12/23/2015 - almost certainly an F5; may well have been stronger than Mayfield-Bremen
The 1953 Vicksburg, MS tornado was an F5 that happened on December 5th
 
That’s easily the most extreme vehicle damage I’ve ever seen from a tornado by a long shot, good lord. This thing also tracked in basically the middle of no where in very rural areas, meaning debris had little effect and that was just the raw power of the tornado shredding those vehicles like that. Can’t imagine what it would’ve done had it tracked through a populated city.
So I came upon this post way back in the thread I somehow missed, vehicle damage from Plainfield that is similar to Stratton in one pic, thankfully this thing peaked over an area with no buildings, but the vehicle damage shows it definitely was F5 for a brief moment:

 
So one of my long, long, long-term projects is to rework and significantly expand my old Tri-State Tornado article in time for the 100th anniversary. I've been doing a little bit of work on it here and there when the mood strikes, and I've made quite a bit of progress on my map:


I still have a few other tornadoes to add and the KY tornadoes need a bit of tweaking, but the Tri-State itself (both track/direction and width) should be about as accurate as it's possible to be nearly a century after the fact. I also started marking the fatalities, but that's obviously going to be a ridiculously involved process and so far I've only finished Hamilton County, IL.

Anyway, the total length of the main tornado as I have it here is 220.5 miles if you measure straight from start to end or 222.1 miles if you follow the actual contours. It's possible this was indeed a single continuous path, but if the tornado did cycle, the most likely spot is north of Saco in Madison County, MO.

QiQAzUB.png


If we treat that gap as a true break, we end up with the Ellington-Annapolis, MO section being ~41 miles and the main Tri-State path being ~179. I feel reasonably confident saying the rest of the path is probably a single tornado. Conversely, the short sections before and after the main track are almost certainly separate tornadoes.

It's been talked about plenty of times before, but what's staggering about this tornado is not just that it had such a long path, but that it remained remarkably large and violent throughout virtually all of it. It reached ~1.2 mi wide near Biehle, MO and later maxed out at just under 1.5 mi wide near Dale, IL. Even more impressively, from about Cherokee Pass, MO to south of Wheeling, IN (a distance of ~169 mi) it appears its width never fell below half a mile. Obviously there were sections where the most intense damage swath was fairly narrow, but for the most part it was unusually wide. It probably first reached violent intensity northeast of Annapolis, MO and, aside from the section in Madison County that was too remote to really be documented, it more or less maintained it all the way to Princeton, IN and beyond. Interestingly, there are even reports of ground scouring in numerous places across all three states.

I also have the long-track F4 near the TN/KY border divided into two paths, each rated F4 (though either could potentially warrant an F5 IMO - especially the first). It definitely cycled quickly in the vicinity of Trammel Creek in far northwestern Macon County, TN. Multiple people reported seeing it lift and reform + there was heavy debris fallout but no actual damage there. The second tornado touched down just before crossing the KY border and causing devastation near Holland. It's possible it may've cycled again either north of Lamb or east of Mt. Hermon but I need to research it more. If it did then all three tornadoes probably deserve an F4 because there was high-end destruction in Beaumont near the very end of the path.

Haven't finished mapping it yet, but one of the members of the tornado family in central KY (Fayette County, up near Lexington) likely reached F4 intensity too, although Grazulis has the whole family as a single long-track F3. Even without the Tri-State Tornado, this would've been a pretty high-end event.

(Side note: I also thought it was mildly interesting that the Laconia F4 southwest of Louisville touched down in basically the exact spot where the Brandenburg F5 crossed the Ohio River.)

59dm9Hk.png

The more I read about eyewitness descriptions of the Tri-State tornado the more I'm convinced it likely did cycle somewhere in the woods north of Saco, MO. When you read about the tornado near Cherokee Pass every description of it says it began to steadily widen while at the same time becoming rain-wrapped; I think this is the main Tri-State being seen, likely not long after touchdown. It wouldn't surprise me if it achieved F5 intensity within seconds of touching down like extreme events tend to.
 
The more I read about eyewitness descriptions of the Tri-State tornado the more I'm convinced it likely did cycle somewhere in the woods north of Saco, MO. When you read about the tornado near Cherokee Pass every description of it says it began to steadily widen while at the same time becoming rain-wrapped; I think this is the main Tri-State being seen, likely not long after touchdown. It wouldn't surprise me if it achieved F5 intensity within seconds of touching down like extreme events tend to.
Possibly, but even if it did, I am very confident it was the same tornado throughout all of Illinois. Still the damage intensity, swath and direction do line up which would be very coincidental imo. I managed to find complete aerial imagery in 1938 of Illinois and could still make out the scar of the tornado, if only i could find one for Missouri.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top