• Welcome to TalkWeather!
    We see you lurking around TalkWeather! Take the extra step and join us today to view attachments, see less ads and maybe even join the discussion.
    CLICK TO JOIN TALKWEATHER
  • April 2024 Weather Video of the Month
    Post your nominations now!

Severe Weather Threat 5/25-5/26, 2024

Jellyroll

Member
Messages
42
Reaction score
118
Location
Illinois
I'm MAD. This was in NWS Fort Worth's CWA. They didn't upgrade the tornado warning for at least half an hour. Shame on them.
And no, I don't care if the general public doesn't understand between 'radar-indicated', 'radar-confirmed' and 'PDS'. If that's true then why issue them to begin with?
I'm mad as well but with my anger directed elsewhere. The "Gov" contracted radars for the NWS in the 80's. These radars were designed in the 70's. The contract was for a certain quantity with a few spares. As of the mid 2000's, no more spares exist. The NWS has done an amazing job updating the hardware and software for these 40-year-old radars but their capacity in terms of coverage and technology has pretty much been exhausted. No matter how talented the folks are at the NWS, in the case of a severe weather outbreaks, they have been hamstrung due to outdated and insufficient technology. Our fine military industrial complex has been cranking out far superior radar technology for 20 years, but sadly these great advances have not been granted by in large to our NWS folks. Not only are the NWS folks hampered by this, but since all the fancy screens and flashy blinkies we look at are from the NWS's feeds, our weather community as a whole is hampered as well. So, Kudos to the NWS folks as well as the spotters and professionals from this community for doing their level best, but if you feel rage at events such as this, send a nastygram to your congressman.
 

rushdude

Member
Messages
87
Reaction score
159
Location
Texas

Man…. Got hit hard
All these poor people - injured and killed - were planning on having a nice holiday weekend. Throwing burgers, steaks, and hot dogs on the grill, fishing, watch the hockey game.. and instead they have to deal with this.

My heart goes out to them
 

TornadoFan17

Member
Messages
337
Reaction score
672
Location
Olive Branch, Mississippi
Special Affiliations
  1. SKYWARN® Volunteer
I'm MAD. This was in NWS Fort Worth's CWA. They didn't upgrade the tornado warning for at least half an hour. Shame on them.
And no, I don't care if the general public doesn't understand between 'radar-indicated', 'radar-confirmed' and 'PDS'. If that's true then why issue them to begin with?
You really seem to have some unbridled rage toward the NWS and everything associated with them. It sounds really childish.

I promise you they are doing the best they can with the tools they have.
 
Messages
423
Reaction score
1,166
Location
Kentucky
You really seem to have some unbridled rage toward the NWS and everything associated with them. It sounds really childish.

I promise you they are doing the best they can with the tools they have.
What? You couldn’t tell that between the posts trying to “talk” directly to the tornado. Where he was asking it to “please stop because the damage it was doing is shameful”? Or the 5000 posts in all caps lol. What about all the ones where he was up in arms over a tornado emergency not being called?
 
Last edited:

jiharris0220

Member
Messages
829
Reaction score
2,355
Location
Wichita Falls
You really seem to have some unbridled rage toward the NWS and everything associated with them. It sounds really childish.

I promise you they are doing the best they can with the tools they have.
I can’t stress this enough, people truly don’t realize how blessed we are to have agencies like the NWS, these people are responsible for all of the products weather enthusiasts use to live stream, make updates, and make forecasts.

If it wasn’t for the NWS, dozens to hundreds of people would die from every moderately significant outbreak.

These folks work under countless hours of extreme stress and uncertainty, wondering if they actually did everything right when people still end up dead despite all the warnings.

They do the best they can with the outdated and underfunded technology presented to them, meteorology is one of the hardest jobs on the planet and one of the most shat on too.

I have nothing but upmost respect to the NWS and it’s people despite their flaws, obviously nobody is without them.
 

jiharris0220

Member
Messages
829
Reaction score
2,355
Location
Wichita Falls
What? You couldn’t tell that between the posts trying to “talk” directly to the tornado. Where he was asking it to “please stop because what it’s doing is shameful”? Or the 5000 posts in all caps lol. What about all the ones where he was up in arms over a tornado emergency not being called?
You couldn’t imagine how much I had to hold my tongue being constantly bombarded with capital letters every 5 seconds. lol
 

slenker

Member
Messages
95
Reaction score
230
Location
Columbus, OH
I can’t stress this enough, people truly don’t realize how blessed we are to have agencies like the NWS, these people are responsible for all of the products weather enthusiasts use to live stream, make updates, and make forecasts.

If it wasn’t for the NWS, dozens to hundreds of people would die from every moderately significant outbreak.

These folks work under countless hours of extreme stress and uncertainty, wondering if they actually did everything right when people still end up dead despite all the warnings.

They do the best they can with the outdated and underfunded technology presented to them, meteorology is one of the hardest jobs on the planet and one of the most shat on too.

I have nothing but upmost respect to the NWS and it’s people despite their flaws, obviously nobody is without them.
Yea, and in a spring like this one? Of course they’re going to be working as hard as possible. The people working for the NWS are some of the smartest people on the planet, and of course they aren’t perfect, but they’re doing the best they can. For people to get this upset at them, they must be more qualified to work the job than the NWS forecasters, right?
 

Maxis_s

Member
Messages
1,169
Reaction score
1,997
Location
Canada
You really seem to have some unbridled rage toward the NWS and everything associated with them. It sounds really childish.

I promise you they are doing the best they can with the tools they have.
Despite all my issues with how the NWS operates, I don't have rage towards the entire thing. I can absolutely understand how hard their job is, and they are by far the best in the world at what they do, and second place doesn't come even close. Trust me, as a Canadian, I know how awful our warning systems are, especially compared to the NWS.
However, the office in Fort Worth had reports from storm spotters and EMS for a long time before the warning was confirmed. That's why I was so upset. Sure, the radar was noisy and it was very hard to discern anything, but when you have multiple reports from the ground, it's obvious you should upgrade it. Combined with a tornado emergency being issued over quite literally nothing the day prior, all the controversial inconsistencies with warnings between all the offices, and just being in a bad mood from other stuff, I ended up acting completely irrationally. I'm very sorry for that, still.
What? You couldn’t tell that between the posts trying to “talk” directly to the tornado. Where he was asking it to “please stop because what it’s doing is shameful”? Or the 5000 posts in all caps lol. What about all the ones where he was up in arms over a tornado emergency not being called?
Yeah, me typing in all caps and getting all worked up over this was really, really stupid of me. I get way too obsessed over this stuff; I'm a dumb weenie, probably not much better than the cesspit that is WXTwitter. It's hard for me to contextualize and understand that there's a team of people who are stressed as hell behind all the warnings being issued, especially when all I'm looking at myself is just colorful pixels on a screen.
And I was trying to "talk" to the tornado because I jinxed several times when warnings were issued, so I thought it would be funny to "talk" to the tornado and jinx it into suddenly dissipating, without reading the room or realizing that I was making a complete fool out of myself.
I'm mad as well but with my anger directed elsewhere. The "Gov" contracted radars for the NWS in the 80's. These radars were designed in the 70's. The contract was for a certain quantity with a few spares. As of the mid 2000's, no more spares exist. The NWS has done an amazing job updating the hardware and software for these 40-year-old radars but their capacity in terms of coverage and technology has pretty much been exhausted. No matter how talented the folks are at the NWS, in the case of a severe weather outbreaks, they have been hamstrung due to outdated and insufficient technology. Our fine military industrial complex has been cranking out far superior radar technology for 20 years, but sadly these great advances have not been granted by in large to our NWS folks. Not only are the NWS folks hampered by this, but since all the fancy screens and flashy blinkies we look at are from the NWS's feeds, our weather community as a whole is hampered as well. So, Kudos to the NWS folks as well as the spotters and professionals from this community for doing their level best, but if you feel rage at events such as this, send a nastygram to your congressman.
I agree. I wish I could send a message to some congessman but I'm from Canada, so... that's not happening until I move to the US.
At least OU is trying out the new Horus radar system, so that should hopefully change stuff.
A bit off-topic but, technically speaking, wouldn't it be difficult on the IEM servers to handle so many updates and scans with the new Horus radar, since it updates every few seconds? The scans are already 10mb+ each in file size, and getting possibly tens or hundreds of thousands of GET requests every second for those files has to have some sort of strain, both on the IEM server and radar apps if they begin polling/updating every few seconds instead of every 30 seconds to 1 minute.

I'm likely gonna try and just lurk for the next dew days or weeks rather than constantly talking unless I seriously have some questions or meaningful input to add, and I'm very sorry for completely ruining the quality of this thread.
 

Jellyroll

Member
Messages
42
Reaction score
118
Location
Illinois
Despite all my issues with how the NWS operates, I don't have rage towards the entire thing. I can absolutely understand how hard their job is, and they are by far the best in the world at what they do, and second place doesn't come even close. Trust me, as a Canadian, I know how awful our warning systems are, especially compared to the NWS.
However, the office in Fort Worth had reports from storm spotters and EMS for a long time before the warning was confirmed. That's why I was so upset. Sure, the radar was noisy and it was very hard to discern anything, but when you have multiple reports from the ground, it's obvious you should upgrade it. Combined with a tornado emergency being issued over quite literally nothing the day prior, all the controversial inconsistencies with warnings between all the offices, and just being in a bad mood from other stuff, I ended up acting completely irrationally. I'm very sorry for that, still.

Yeah, me typing in all caps and getting all worked up over this was really, really stupid of me. I get way too obsessed over this stuff; I'm a dumb weenie, probably not much better than the cesspit that is WXTwitter. It's hard for me to contextualize and understand that there's a team of people who are stressed as hell behind all the warnings being issued, especially when all I'm looking at myself is just colorful pixels on a screen.
And I was trying to "talk" to the tornado because I jinxed several times when warnings were issued, so I thought it would be funny to "talk" to the tornado and jinx it into suddenly dissipating, without reading the room or realizing that I was making a complete fool out of myself.

I agree. I wish I could send a message to some congessman but I'm from Canada, so... that's not happening until I move to the US.
At least OU is trying out the new Horus radar system, so that should hopefully change stuff.
A bit off-topic but, technically speaking, wouldn't it be difficult on the IEM servers to handle so many updates and scans with the new Horus radar, since it updates every few seconds? The scans are already 10mb+ each in file size, and getting possibly tens or hundreds of thousands of GET requests every second for those files has to have some sort of strain, both on the IEM server and radar apps if they begin polling/updating every few seconds instead of every 30 seconds to 1 minute.

I'm likely gonna try and just lurk for the next dew days or weeks rather than constantly talking unless I seriously have some questions or meaningful input to add, and I'm very sorry for completely ruining the quality of this thread.
Your question is a little off topic but folks would be happy to discuss in depth on other forums here. Suffice to say, you're stepping in the answer to your own question. Not only the radars need updating for the network / hardware / processing systems as a whole would need updating. OU has been testing the latest and greatest radar technology for decades but it seems that its only pocket change to the government so they can say "we're trying" "maybe you'll get full funding next year". One radar at OU does not an integrated network make. Just like everything else, substantive change only comes with substantive investment.
 
Back
Top