Note his use of the word “special”
Exactly. That's why I'm extremely confused that anyone is questioning that claim. I don't think any *group* as a whole possesses some kind of special or unique ability to define or discern racism. I believe it varies significantly on an individual basis, and it has a lot to do with one's background, experience, and a host of other factors.
How many times have we seen someone say or do something OBVIOUSLY racist in public yet argue repeatedly that what they said or did "had nothing to do with race." And if matters not one bit if the person is white, black, Hispanic, Asian, or purple. We've all seen situations like that. It's like some of the BLM people who said that they "hate white people" but can't be racist because they're black. Or, white supremacists who say they have "No problem with black people as long as they're in Africa. We're not racists -- we just think people should stick to their own kind." I think some of those people genuinely believe their own BS.
Again, I'm honestly baffled that my quote there is seen as controversial.
As I said earlier in my post, I do think someone's perspective of race is often based on multiple variables and factors. Some of those variables include geography (where someone was born, grew up, and lives) as well as age. There quite a few additional variables, and I'm not suggesting that geography and age are the most important variables, nor am I saying those variables predestine someone to a certain perspective.
I've mentioned this before, but someone whose formative years were in the 1950's to mid 1980's likely experienced an America quite different than the people people who grew up before and after them. The United States' foreign born population as a percentage of total population has been 8% or higher every decade since 1850 except for 1950, 1960, 1970, and 1980. I'm fact, the percentage was double digits from 1850 - 1930s, and then went back to double digits sometime in the late 1990s to 2000.
Census Data showing % of foreign born population
Now, we're at almost 14% as of our population as foreign born.
2017 showed that 13.7% of the US population is foreign born and continues to increase.
Additionally, the country of origin of our foreign born population is quite different today than it was 50 years ago or 100 years ago.
It's hard to argue that doesn't have an impact on attitudes and perceptions. Someone who was born in 1990 likely grew up around a lot more immigrants, and those immigrants were much much much more likely to be Latin-American or Asian than than European. That's a comparatively very different experience than the one someone might have experienced that was born in 1950 or 1960.
Obviously, someone who grew up in a border area of Texas in 1960 would've had a somewhat similar experience as someone born in 1990 in an area where the vast majority of immigrants were from Mexico, so it's definitely not a hard rule.
The point is, age, geography, social class, and even things like religion influence people's attitudes on matters of race, immigration, and culture. Catholics, for instance, usually spent more time around certain immigrant groups than their Protestant brethren. Even now that may hold true in some areas as a lot of Hispanics tend to be Catholic and attend Catholic churches.
None of this is meant to imply that being born in a certain place or time means that someone is racist or a bigot. Please don't make the mistake that many "woke" liberals make and assume that one's background is destiny. Or, that someone is unable to inherently see and treat people as equal unless they're a minority or a woke progressive. Simply not the case. But, to think that the variables I mentioned don't have an influence on people's attitudes and perspectives is just as wrong.
You can see the influence of these things on a fairly regular basis. It's why some people in rural areas that didn't have much immigration until the past 20-30 years sometimes see immigrants as "invaders" while some young people in cities think those in the rural areas are just a bunch of racists. Neither group seems to understand the perspective of the other group, nor do they seem to be aware of why their perspectives are so different.
Americans have stopped talking to each other or attempting to understand why people have different opinions and perspectives. It's one of the reasons I think populist/nationalist politicians like Trump and "woke progressive" Democrats are so toxic for this country. Instead of trying to bridge those gaps, they're pandering to one side or the other, and at the same time are demonizing the other side as unapproachable reprobates. The end result is that people retreat into their balkanized echo chambers instead of trying to find common ground.