• Welcome to TalkWeather!
    We see you lurking around TalkWeather! Take the extra step and join us today to view attachments, see less ads and maybe even join the discussion.
    CLICK TO JOIN TALKWEATHER

Significant Tornado Events

It may seem pedantic, but when talking about the top most violent tornadoes then it becomes a very relevant hallmark.

Tornadoes that produce 100% debarking of hardwood, especially mesquite trees are what separates them from the rest. The feat being so incredibly rare is one of the reasons why I place matador on the same level as Jarrel, Smithville, Bridge Creek, and Moore.

Piedmont also achieved 100% debarking as well if I remember correctly.
 
Last edited:
jiharris0220 said:
It may seem pedantic, but when talking about the top most violent tornadoes then it becomes a very relevant hallmark.

Tornadoes that produce 100% debarking of hardwood, especially mesquite trees are what separates them from the rest. The feat being so incredibly rare is one of the reasons why I place matador on the same level as Jarrel, Smithville, Bridge Creek, and Moore.

Piedmont also achieved 100% debarking as well if I remember correctly.
Click to expand...
Okay, as far as the question of "what was the worst debarking [x tornado] produced?" you're right about that.

Still, the shear level of destruction Bassfield did to that entire grove of hardwood trees is something basically unparalleled in the tornado world, especially since I'd estimate about half of those trees (and others elsewhere) lost 100% of their bark. The only comparable damage I've seen done to dense groves of hardwood trees occurred in Smithville and Hackleburg.
 
And to add, I'll honestly have to agree that some of the damage Matador produced was very Bridge Creek-esque, albeit in a much smaller area. One home on the north side of town actually did have some anchoring, albeit it wasn't well built enough for an EF5 rating. If this home had a solid poured concrete foundation with proper anchor bolts all the way around, an EF5 rating would have been necessary imo. I've previously mentioned that in an email conversation I had with Tim Marshall after the tornado, he alluded that the contextual damage definitely pointed to a higher intensity but the construction quality prevented a higher rating. Not sure how I feel about that, as I've seen homes destroyed by other tornadoes that were of equal or worse construction than the Matador home get an EF4 rating (I never got an explanation to why this home wasn't rated as such)
image-481-png.20932
 
TH2002 said:
I don't agree with your assessment of Bassfield. It didn't just produce what is arguably the most significant tree debarking ever photographed - vehicles were hurled hundreds of yards and torn to pieces, a cabin (albeit not well built apart from being anchored) literally disappeared with the little debris that remained from it being finely granulated, every single anchor bolt at the property was flattened or ripped from the slab, wind rowing occurred, and grass was scoured.
eqneuq_xeaamwqw-jpeg.7973

qq%E6%88%AA%E5%9B%BE20210306001809-jpg.7976

qq%E5%9B%BE%E7%89%8720200417193210-png.8169

qq%E5%9B%BE%E7%89%8720210402182909-png.8168

qq%E6%88%AA%E5%9B%BE20210202224416-jpg.8165

e8ae2c6c-0aee-499c-8a27-666a9550fd12-jpeg.25358

8f985688-35a5-4145-8861-cf52bd87b143-jpeg.25362

14fbfb21-08fe-44aa-8d9d-21849879dbe4-jpeg.25363
Click to expand...

Adding onto Bassfield, that thing was an absolute monster and undoubtedly well into the EF5 category. Here’s a few extra photos of impressive contextual damage before the tornado had even reached its maximum intensity:
2F534C78-5628-42B2-B1CB-DD2CFE7FAA8C.jpeg6908F7CF-ADDC-44B2-A019-8207E61FBFD1.jpeg
4074DE7F-D26F-4B36-B4C1-7A99D8912FF2.jpeg

Here’s the frame of a truck and steel support beams wrapped around a tree.
26EFB5DB-3025-473E-9E40-9E52DCC7EED8.jpeg
A3B774F1-225A-4BA9-BF21-83D687FEDA89.jpeg
 
Western_KS_Wx said:
Adding onto Bassfield, that thing was an absolute monster and undoubtedly well into the EF5 category. Here’s a few extra photos of impressive contextual damage before the tornado had even reached its maximum intensity:
View attachment 29418View attachment 29419
View attachment 29421

Here’s the frame of a truck and steel support beams wrapped around a tree.
View attachment 29422
View attachment 29423
Click to expand...
Sheesh. That debarked low lying shrubbery in the top photo is insane. My claim is that Bassfield is on the same level as Vilonia, just hit more rural areas than Vilonia did.
 
Western_KS_Wx said:
Adding onto Bassfield, that thing was an absolute monster and undoubtedly well into the EF5 category. Here’s a few extra photos of impressive contextual damage before the tornado had even reached its maximum intensity:
View attachment 29418View attachment 29419
View attachment 29421

Here’s the frame of a truck and steel support beams wrapped around a tree.
View attachment 29422
View attachment 29423
Click to expand...
Ok, that picture of the truck frame fully convinced me.

Based off the recent photos y’all shared, I will change my opinion of this tornado in that it was a solid Ef5.

Although still not quite Matador, Smithville, Jarrel, or Bridge Creek level, mainly due to lack of persistent solid ground scoring and trees not being 100% debarked.

Nevertheless, this tornado is easily above, Bremen, Rolling Fork, and Joplin contextually.
 
Last edited:
Yesterday, the 160,000-acre Park Fire near Chico, CA has now been classified as a Tornadic Pyrosupercell Firestorm. At least 1 Class 3 Fire Tornado has been reported by CalFire, yet so far, the tornado has not caused any significant damage. Once the fire is contained, there may be a chance a damage survey by CalFire and the National Weather Service will be carried out.
 
Also, this is the 6th anniversary of the devastating 2018 Carr Fire tornado that killed 4 individuals and injured 6. It was rated a Low to Mid EF3 with winds between 136-146 mph, yet the damage photos showed scenes of destruction similar to that of a nuclear bomb.

Swegle Studios has a video on this type of phenomenon if you want to check it out. Pretty useful info if you ask me.
 
So it looks like there another confirmed victim of the Tri State Tornado in Missouri. So in this archived newspaper link https://shsmo.newspapers.com/image/687685884/?match=1&terms=Four dead in Biehle injuries blechle
It says that August Joseph Lappe will died of his injury to his head on February 23th, 1926 when the house he and his family were living in near Biehle was demolished. So now the final victim of the tornado dies on February 23th instead of January 3rd. And the death toll in Missouri is raised by 1, and Biehle’s death toll is now 2 identified and 2 unidentified instead of 1 identified and 3 unidentified.IMG_2596.png
 
Last edited:
Aaron Rider said:
Check out Loco's post on his blog

Click to expand...
Reading this again over coffee this morning, I note that this outbreak had 6 F4s that are all in the same category I'd describe as "very, very, VERY high end F4" not just regular F4

Tionesta, Moshannon, Kane, Atlantic, Albion, and Barrie are all in this category. But the available images from Barrie do incline me to think it would be fair to categorize it as an F5.

Of course, coming from Pennsylvania, I've spent much of my life in the woods and so I can flatly say that it wasn't just Moshannon that went through wilderness or close to it.
 
locomusic01 said:
Speaking of West Frankfort, here are some others (some of which were taken SW of town I believe) that I don't think have been posted here before:

Oof7qQJ.jpeg


945Kmo8.jpeg


Zkhtt5s.jpeg


EOMtNkc.jpeg


sjxWigz.jpeg


YrRm0UE.jpeg


SI9x4S3.jpeg


3Pb1We5.jpeg


xigg0dk.jpeg


t43UIGd.jpeg


iiUITNT.jpeg


XItPS7e.jpeg


i5NM2Dq.jpeg


Also the M&O Shops in Murphysboro:

TKdAaqY.jpeg


rw3WgCW.jpeg


And two from near Frohna, MO:

wFgbliv.jpeg


Ov37Vns.jpeg
Click to expand...
Where did you get those images of West Frankfort from? I have never seen them before.
 
I completely forgot about the 20th anniversary of the 2004 Roanoke F4, so I'll post now.

On July 13, 2004, a powerful F4 tornado formed outside Roanoke, IL. It is best known for the numerous videos and pictures taken of it as well as the complete destruction of the Parsons Manufacturing plant. Despite the violent intensity, there were only three minor injuries and no fatalities. It was one of six tornadoes to touch down on July 13, 2004.

 
So according to most books and website (not including Wikipedia) it said that the Tri State Tornado killed 4 people and injured 11 in Biehle or in it’s vicinity, but when I did my research I only found 2 who were killed in the Biehle area. Joseph Blechle who was killed instantly and August Lappe who died of his injuries in February the next year, so were the other 2 victims killed in the Biehle area?

Also the same books also said that the tornado killed 4 more people and injured 25 in the Rural area in Perry county after Biehle, but I only found 3 who were killed. Martha Kaempfe who was killed instantly, Crittenden Bull who died 4 days later, and Louise Stueve who died 10 days later, so who was the other victim to be killed in the rural area of Perry County after Biehle?
 
I did research on all tornadoes in 2024 that Dopper on wheels recorded to be 200 mph or over, but were give a non ef5 rating.

The 2 tornados I found that were definitely ef5 in all but name were the Harlan, Iowa tornado on April 26th with 224 mph and the Greenfield, Iowa tornado on May 21th with 309 to 318 mph.

Let me know if there were any other tornadoes on 2024 that were measured by Dopper on wheels to have wind speeds over 200 mph?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top