Alabama swing counties?
Tuscaloosa County, home to the University of Alabama and Lee County, home to Auburn University went big for Trump in 2016. Trump won Tuscaloosa by 19 and Lee by 23.
On Tuesday, they headed in the opposite direction and went Jones. The Democrat won each of those counties by 17 points.
Many people thought Jones could improve upon Hillary Clinton’s 2016 performance, but no one foresaw Jones winning and winning by such a margin.
That was huge. Also huge was that Shelby and Baldwin County both had THOUSANDS less votes for Moore in 2017 compared to Moore. I think one had 20k less votes and the other had 25k less. I had it written down somewhere as I was doing manual calculations all last night compared to 2012 Moore/Vance race.
I did some research a few days ago on Alabama voter registration. Normally there is a 35-60k drop in black voter registrations in the year after a Presidential election. Has happened for the last 3 or 4 Presidential elections. This year? Only a 6k drop. That told me that black voters were energized and were going to come out in vote. They didn't exceed their 2016 vote totals, but they didn't have to. They simply needed to turnout close to the level seen in a major election and they did.
In analyzing the polls done a week before the election, I noticed that all the polls showing Moore with a lead were only showing black voters as making up 22-25% of the voter pool. That was UNDER their normal representative pop.
Additionally, the live interview polls were better representing what I was hearing from friends and family members anecdotally. It was overestimating enthusiasm among GOP voters, and almost all the polls strongly for Moore were REGISTERED voters instead of likely voters. Huge difference in a special election.
I could go on and on, but I made a prediction on Sunday. I said I was extremely confident it would be between +2 for Moore and +2 for Jones, but had the possibility of being anywhere from Jones +4 to Moore +8. If you understand polling ranges and uncertainty you will get what I'm talking about. In my final analysis yesterday at 7:56am I worked it out that the election would be Jones +2.8.
I put my money where my mouth was. I bought hundreds of contracts on PredictIt that Jones would win Madison and Mobile counties, and that he would defeat Moore. Made a nice profit.
I wavered last night after seeing the 2nd data dump from exit polls. Moore was doing better with college educated voters than I had worked out. It was such an intense night with dozens of manual calculations that I forgot about something simple. One, exit polls have high MOE. Two, voters may LIE about their vote or demographics when asked by an exit poller. If you didn't attend college and planned to vote for Moore, you might tell someone you did go to college when someone with a Northern accent stops you outside a poll.
But Exit polls also showed black voters turning out at 30%. I saw that first hand at my polling place. Black voter turn out was up a good 15-20% compared to the special election.
At any rate, the clincher for me was Houston County. When they had over 90% of the vote in early on (I think 4th County to be over 80% of returns in), Moore was receiving 5% less votes as a share of the overall quantity compared to 2012. Only two things could've explained that. GOP voters staying at home/writing in/voting for Jones, as an increase in the black vote there wouldn't create a 5% difference.
I was pretty confident at that point and bought more contracts on PredictIt.
The only thing that shocks me is Shelby County and Baldwin. I really thought more voters there would blindly vote GOP and just hold their nose. Not a lot wrote in votes or backed Jones. It was more that they just didn't vote. They stayed at home.
I actually think Moore overperformed in many rural areas. Cullman County, Fayette County, and a couple of others were very noticeable. Cullman had like a 13% Moore increase compared to 2012. Those voters bought the Establishment/Swamp vs. MAGA narrative. Know who didn't? Shelby and Baldwin County voters. Madison County voters. Jefferson County Over the Mountain voters. Bannon and others came in screaming about the Establishment and even knocked U of A. They forgot how many GOP voters in those counties are business/Establishment kind of voters that hate the stereotype that people in Alabama live in a trailer and have 2 teeth.
I mean, I'd imagine Moore was massacred in places like Mountain Brook/Vestavia, affluent suburbs in Madison/Baldwin, and the Highway 280 corridor. That was a massively idiotic error by Bannon and others, but that's what you get with outsiders.