• Welcome to TalkWeather!
    We see you lurking around TalkWeather! Take the extra step and join us today to view attachments, see less ads and maybe even join the discussion.
    CLICK TO JOIN TALKWEATHER

Severe Weather Threat - Jan 11-12th, 2024

andyhb said:
The LLJ doesn't really have much to do with this IMO. It's 55-70 kts out of the SSW, which is more than plenty for a big severe day down here (actually would probably favor it over the due south LLJ given moisture trajectories in the SE). Additionally, the low level response here was always further north and the trough is lifting away with time, which limits forcing for ascent. The thermos just aren't there due to the cold front earlier this week and combining that with decreased large scale ascent is a death knell for stronger convection.

Put 1500-2000 J/kg CAPE over this warm sector and you're talking a potential high risk event. I should say the timing is also a bit off, the most favorable period of the trough's evolution was 2-6 hours ago. This might not matter much though if the temperatures and dewpoints were 10 degrees higher.
Click to expand...

Gotcha, thanks. Most of the forecast soundings I saw were pretty much due southwesterly at 850mb, not south-southwesterly. Also, some of the soundings I saw for Tuesday's event had close to 80kts at that level.

As to the second bolded, absolutely.
 
i don't claim to be a meteorologist. common sense dictates that January severe events are relatively rare in north Alabama. there are, of course, exceptions. January events more typically occur over south Alabama. also, the temperatures today just seemed way too low to be conducive to tornado formation. we didn't have warm southwest winds howling. while i have seen a few decent thunderstorms when it's in the 50's outside, they seem to require a whole lot to be going right in the atmosphere to form and typically do not last long. also, when nothing is going on to the west of us, given the same daunting weather data sets and predictions, nothing tends to happen here.

the professional meteorologists should try to step away from their data sometime and remember some very basic facts of existence in Alabama before they compose a forecast. what has happened to common sense? while this event could have come together, under absolutely ideal conditions, the odds were far more in favor of a Forecasted Convective Amplification Deficiency.
 
Last edited:
Me looking rapidly through latest posts on here:

Awkward The Simpsons GIF
 
Forks said:
i don't claim to be a meteorologist. common sense dictates that January severe events are relatively rare in north Alabama. there are, of course, exceptions. January events more typically occur over south Alabama. also, the temperatures today just seemed way too low to be conducive to tornado formation. we didn't have warm southwest winds howling. while i have seen a few decent thunderstorms when it's in the 50's outside, they seem to require a whole lot to be going right in the atmosphere to form and typically do not last long. also, when nothing is going on to the west of us, given the same daunting weather data sets and predictions, nothing tends to happen here.

the professional meteorologists should try to step away from their data sometime and remember some very basic facts of existence in Alabama before they compose a forecast. what has happened to common sense? while this event could have come together, under absolutely ideal conditions, the odds were far more in favor of a Forecasted Convective Amplification Deficiency.
Click to expand...
Which is exactly why the SPC didn't upgrade the risk area to MDT.

Yes, today's tornado potential was oversold. So what? Forecasting is an imperfect science. I don't understand why people have to be oh so quick to attack meteorologists and forecasters when an event doesn't live up to its highest ceiling. As for common sense, it left the thread when it devolved into an argument about school closures.
 
Not gonna lie I expected better from this site.
Reading the comments on this thread feels no different than Facebook or twitter.
Sometimes things Forecasted Convective Amplification Deficiency and sometimes things over perform, instead of nagging at the weather service, shouldn’t we be glad sh&t didn’t hit the fan?
 
TH2002 said:
Which is exactly why the SPC didn't upgrade the risk area to MDT.

Yes, today's tornado potential was oversold. So what? Forecasting is an imperfect science. I don't understand why people have to be oh so quick to attack meteorologists and forecasters when an event doesn't live up to its highest ceiling. As for common sense, it left the thread when it devolved into an argument about school closures.
Click to expand...
I just want to apologize for my part in what transpired in this thread. I let my emotions get the better of me when I should not have let them.
 
Chris3024 said:
I just want to apologize for my part in what transpired in this thread. I let my emotions get the better of me when I should not have let them.
Click to expand...
No need to apologize to me since I'm not a moderator or anything, but don't fret, it happens. I'll admit my previous post was a bit emotionally charged too lol
 
TH2002 said:
No need to apologize to me since I'm not a moderator or anything, but don't fret, it happens. I'll admit my previous post was a bit emotionally charged too lol
Click to expand...

Trust me, it took a LOT of self-restraint on my part not to say anything. However, I hope everyone has it out of their system, because this forum will not become Twitter.
 
pritchlaw said:
Oh there is no doubt it all starts with the forecasters. I said as much early on in this discussion. The battle for viewers is the root cause of this crap forecasting.
Click to expand...
I do provide decision support for schools, and the overwhelming majority do not rely on tv news stations for their guidance. It is the local NWS office or EMA. Maybe your school district does, so take it up with the Superintendent.
 
Last edited:
pritchlaw said:
You got me. I'm not a school administrator. But I don't need to be a pilot to say a plane shouldn't leave the runway without enough to gas to get where it’s going. You sound like the "and where did you get your medical degree" crowd during Covid.
Click to expand...
You sound triggered lol

I only ask because people always have something to say about a life they have never lived before.

That’s all I’m saying.
 
pritchlaw said:
No, I send them there to get an education and don't like the schools closing 10 times a year for a weather event that was over-hyped and never was a threat, like today. So instead of learning like other kids, they are all at home and their teachers are at Buffalo Wild Wings yucking it up about how stupid the school closure was. Got any other hot takes there?
Click to expand...
Here’s a hot take:

You don’t have to stay in unpredictable Dixie Alley *IF* schools closing bothers you that much :)
 
pritchlaw said:
We can have this same discussion Monday and Tuesday when schools close bc of the possibility of winter precip which, if it happens at all, will prove to not have been bad enough to close schools again. The hype for that event will begin in a few hours after the final tiny possibility of a tree falling somewhere from this level 2/3 severe threat is extinguished.
Click to expand...
Wait. You aren’t taking about schools in the Deep South for winter weather are you? You know, the Deep South where most areas are not prepared for bad winter weather? lol
 
MichelleH said:
Trust me, it took a LOT of self-restraint on my part not to say anything. However, I hope everyone has it out of their system, because this forum will not become Twitter.
Click to expand...
Thank you. I did not start this thread for someone to get on their political soapbox. If I wanted this thread to be about schools closing, etc.

Just when I forget that we can block/ignore someone on here, someone reminds me :)
 
Last edited:
KevinH said:
Thank you. I did not start this thread for someone to get on their political soapbox. If I wanted this thread to be a kit schools closing, etc.

Just when I forget that we can block/ignore someone on here, someone reminds me :)
Click to expand...
Hover around or click on the username.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top