Lake Martin EF4
Member
Done! This shall be the discussion area for the high end tornado that hit Madator, TX on the Summer Solstice.
No QRT with this one.
-
Welcome to TalkWeather! We see you lurking around TalkWeather! Take the extra step and join us today to view attachments, see less ads and maybe even join the discussion. CLICK TO JOIN TALKWEATHER
June 21st 2023 Matador TX Tornado Discussion
- Thread starter Lake Martin EF4
- Start date
No QRT with this one.
Sawmaster
Member
In order to keep all the info in one place (here), could those who posted about this in other threads request their relevant posts be moved (or copied) here? Much discussion/ pics/ vids might be missed with future researchers of what I think is going to be one of the most interesting tornadoes in a very long time..
- Moderator
- #4
We should be able to move the posts over here but it may take a bit. I'll consult with the moderating team and see if we can put a plan together.
tornado examiner
Member
I don’t like the word final in there but……this is weird in other ways
Tanner
Member
tornado examiner
Member
It’s incredibly unlikely…if it does happen prepare for the biggest explosion in wxtwitter history…
tornado examiner
Member
If this one gets rated ef5 over all the others….I just have to say…W H A T ? ?
CheeselandSkies
Member
I've certainly seen plenty of contextual evidence that this was in the upper echelon of violent tornadoes (vehicle hurling/mangling/even shredding, tree shredding/debarking, grass scouring, extensive wind rowing, etc)...but I haven't yet seen anything specific as to what potential EF5 indicators might be.
tornado examiner
Member
That’s what I’m saying…
jiharris0220
Member
Welp, I’m bout ready to throw in the towel on this one.
They surveyed for one day and are already finished?
Thats hardly enough time to determine anything higher than a low end ef4.
I could just be overreacting but I can’t help but think this going to be joining the rare ”ef3s that should’ve ef5”. list. (Westminster and New Wren).
They surveyed for one day and are already finished?
Thats hardly enough time to determine anything higher than a low end ef4.
I could just be overreacting but I can’t help but think this going to be joining the rare ”ef3s that should’ve ef5”. list. (Westminster and New Wren).
tornado examiner
Member
I’m pretty sure more surveys may be conducted…if they don’t do that…then they will be labeled as lazy
Shakespeare 2016
Member
The Greensburg, KS and Parkersburg, IA EF5 tornadoes only took a day or two to get the EF5 rating.
jiharris0220
Member
I mean, I guess that’s a little hopeful. And to make things clear, I’m not saying Matador was an ef5, and I’m not expecting it to be one.
Even though the contextuals are clear cut ef5, I’ve seen no conventional DIs that say nothing of the sort.
I just want the damage survey team to take their time and be as precise as possible in rating this thing.
With that being said, I’m now seeing info about the NWI, and that they are only deployed during the most violent of tornadoes, so maybe this won’t be a botched one.
Even though the contextuals are clear cut ef5, I’ve seen no conventional DIs that say nothing of the sort.
I just want the damage survey team to take their time and be as precise as possible in rating this thing.
With that being said, I’m now seeing info about the NWI, and that they are only deployed during the most violent of tornadoes, so maybe this won’t be a botched one.
tornado examiner
Member
Still though…an ef5 rating isn’t out of the question. We haven’t seen good ground images of most of the slabbed homes yet
Shakespeare 2016
Member
This thread has Matador, TX spelled wrong.
atrainguy
Member
Does NWS Lubbock have a reputation of any kind in regards to rating tornadoes? Like having a tendency to overrate or underrate tornadoes?
jiharris0220
Member
While yes, the prospect of ef5 being designated can’t be ruled out, most of the homes that were slabbed didn’t seem like they had any sort of solid concrete foundation.
Especially the lone house with the green roof and interior basement.
And the two story house that, while slabbed, had a fair amount of debris left over, and looked pretty old too.
Again, not discounting the possibility, but I wouldn’t be surprised if an ef5 rating was assigned off of contextuals instead. It’s happened plenty of time before.
Especially the lone house with the green roof and interior basement.
And the two story house that, while slabbed, had a fair amount of debris left over, and looked pretty old too.
Again, not discounting the possibility, but I wouldn’t be surprised if an ef5 rating was assigned off of contextuals instead. It’s happened plenty of time before.
Last edited:
tornado examiner
Member
Well…tim Marshall is in matador..
And the most interesting di…the slabbed home north of town…wasn’t well built…or anchored well…
Say bye to any ef5 rating that’s for sure now
And the most interesting di…the slabbed home north of town…wasn’t well built…or anchored well…
Say bye to any ef5 rating that’s for sure now
Shakespeare 2016
Member
I don't care I would rate it EF5. I am sick and tired of this crap that we need a well-built home to be completely swept away to get an EF5 rating. Use the contextual damage as it is more telling than a well-built house.
