• Welcome to TalkWeather!
    We see you lurking around TalkWeather! Take the extra step and join us today to view attachments, see less ads and maybe even join the discussion.
    CLICK TO JOIN TALKWEATHER

Enhanced Fujita Ratings Debate Thread

I will say this…I haven’t seen scouring in Oklahoma like that since Moore 2013.
I just got done surveying the most extreme damage from this tornado, and I’ve got to say this is probably the most violent tornado in Oklahoma since Moore ‘13. I photographed areas where the tornado appeared to reach maximum intensity along E Southgate Rd and S 16th St and the damage I saw in those areas was absolutely upper-echelon in the centerline. Extreme scouring to bare soil, shrubbery totally debarked, farm equipment and unidentifiable vehicles stripped to their chassis, etc. I’m getting in position for a chase day in southern Oklahoma right now, but I’ll post photos later. It’s definitely comparable to modern day plains EF5’s.
 
I just got done surveying the most extreme damage from this tornado, and I’ve got to say this is probably the most violent tornado in Oklahoma since Moore ‘13. I photographed areas where the tornado appeared to reach maximum intensity along E Southgate Rd and S 16th St and the damage I saw in those areas was absolutely upper-echelon in the centerline. Extreme scouring to bare soil, shrubbery totally debarked, farm equipment and unidentifiable vehicles stripped to their chassis, etc. I’m getting in position for a chase day in southern Oklahoma right now, but I’ll post photos later. It’s definitely comparable to modern day plains EF5’s.
Quite rare to have such a historically violent tornado hit so much yet kill no-one. A true EF5 contextual tornado that thankfully wasn’t riddled with fatalities. A testament to how good modern warning systems are.
 
Sorry for quoting my own tweet here, but here’s some damage photos from the Enid EF4 I’ve got:


Once I’m done chasing today, I will upload more photos of what I’ve got. Just an extraordinarily violent tornado no doubt about it.

That is incredible contextual damage. The fence posts ripped out of the concrete are insane.
 
Sorry for quoting my own tweet here, but here’s some damage photos from the Enid EF4 I’ve got:


Once I’m done chasing today, I will upload more photos of what I’ve got. Just an extraordinarily violent tornado no doubt about it.

This really settles my firm belief that the Enid tornado definitely reached EF5 strength. At first I thought it likely did, but now i’m 100% confident it did. You never see debarked low lying shrubbery like that out of an EF4. Good lord at that ground scouring as well…
 
I'm seeing so much language from both surveyors and even typically quite conservative experts that they are very impressed with the damage in Enid, that's why I wouldn't be surprised to see a context-based upgrade to high end EF4. I doubt they go EF5, but on the DAT the language isn't super professional in the DI descriptions because it's so incredibly violent. It sounds like they really want to upgrade this thing but the structural aspect is holding them back.
 
EF5 contextuals, no doubt about it. Since I also factor in contextual damage in my interpretation of the EF scale (the LMEF Scale?), I now have this as an EF5. Note that last year didn't have my first surefire EF5 candidate by my book until mid-May, and it took me even longer to decide it was actually an EF5 candidate.
I can get behind the LMEF scale.
 
Back
Top