• Welcome to TalkWeather!
    We see you lurking around TalkWeather! Take the extra step and join us today to view attachments, see less ads and maybe even join the discussion.
    CLICK TO JOIN TALKWEATHER

Severe Weather Threat 09/14/2026 (SE Nebraska to Central Iowa)

I'm fine with a warning. I'm not fine with them stretching it out 45 miles and almost an hour of storm travel time, especially for very weak rotation, almost nonexistent rotation. Telling people "A tornado is possible an hour from now," is what watches are for, not warnings. Warnings are supposed to make people act immediately to seek shelter. Stuff like this is why people don't.
Well, yes, i agree with that. Just don't think the "goobers" bit is necessary even if it not the worst jab I've heard at a NWS office. I'm no innocent at saying stuff about a NWS office either just to clarify. Shamed Baltimore, confirmed there was a tornado within that debacle and so I apologised

The warning length may be due to increased confidence that QLCS action may extend that far East?
 
I'm fine with a warning. I'm not fine with them stretching it out 45 miles and almost an hour of storm travel time, especially for very weak, almost nonexistent rotation. Telling people "A tornado is possible an hour from now," is what watches are for, not warnings. Warnings are supposed to make people act immediately to seek shelter. Stuff like this is why people don't.
this is wmy svr tornado possibles exist
 
NWS Des Moines mets must've fallen asleep. Storm is leaving the polygon and about to slam Des Moines

(Edit: JK it fell apart)


1789438041587.png1789438073222.png
 
Last edited:
Just in general, I think that threads should be reserved for days ahead and not the day of. No point making a thread for 2 pages of discussion that can fit in the SW2026 thread.
 
Just in general, I think that threads should be reserved for days ahead and not the day of. No point making a thread for 2 pages of discussion that can fit in the SW2026 thread.
Agreed. I have no idea why this was made. Usually I don't care whether threads are or are not made since it's petty to argue over but blegh.
 
Just in general, I think that threads should be reserved for days ahead and not the day of. No point making a thread for 2 pages of discussion that can fit in the SW2026 thread.

And if yesterday hit its ceiling people would've been complaining about the lack of a thread. Or you'd have a situation like earlier this year where a thread was made way too late and 10 pages of discussion were in one area, with 5 in another. I made this thread based on the severe weather potential, not the final outcome, which obviously was not known at the time.

I used to share your line of thinking, but then someone shared a big discussion that happened about thread policy a few years ago that changed my mind. The general consensus was that if a specific event is worth discussing in depth, it should be catalogued in its own dedicated thread.
 
or for something like Appleton where something significant enough happened to warrant one
The absolute worst outcome is a thread being made after something big happens. Then the discussion is in two separate areas and it's impossible (or extremely difficult) to track down all of it later on. The purpose of severe weather threads is to catalogue events so they're organized and can be found easily (even years later) when individuals are doing research.
 
And if yesterday hit its ceiling people would've been complaining about the lack of a thread. Or you'd have a situation like earlier this year where a thread was made way too late and 10 pages of discussion were in one area, with 5 in another. I made this thread based on the severe weather potential, not the final outcome, which obviously was not known at the time.

I used to share your line of thinking, but then someone shared a big discussion that happened about thread policy a few years ago that changed my mind. The general consensus was that if a specific event is worth discussing in depth, it should be catalogued in its own dedicated thread.
But here's the thing: this day was outlined 4 days ago meaning there was better lead time for a reasonable thread. It being made yesterday also barely alerted many to the thread at hand, save for your message regarding it. This isn't a big deal to me, and i don't hold threads to a reasonable standard at all. If they're made, they're made but there was time to make this beforehand and there wouldn't have been a "lack of a thread" even if things went opposite which thankfully didn't work out. That's my two cents.
 
Back
Top